What incrementality testing reveals about true marketing ROI?

ROI insights

For Australian SMEs, understanding the *true* return on investment (ROI) from marketing spend can feel like navigating a maze. We often rely on last-click attribution – assuming the final touchpoint before a sale gets all the credit. But this paints an incomplete, and often misleading, picture. Incrementality testing cuts through the noise, revealing what’s genuinely driving growth and what’s simply along for the ride.

Incrementality testing, at its heart, is about measuring the *additional* sales generated by a specific marketing activity. It’s not about overall sales, but the lift you see when you deliberately turn a campaign on or off for a specific group of people. This is a crucial distinction. Here’s what this approach reveals:

  • The Hidden Impact of Brand Building: Many marketing activities, like brand awareness campaigns, don’t result in immediate clicks or conversions. Incrementality testing can demonstrate the delayed impact of these efforts, showing how they contribute to future sales.
  • Channel Overlap & Synergies: We often assume channels work in isolation. Testing reveals how channels interact. For example, you might find that a Facebook campaign only performs well *because* people have already seen your brand on radio.
  • Wasted Spend Identification: It’s easy to continue investing in tactics that *look* good but aren’t actually driving incremental revenue. Testing quickly identifies these areas, allowing you to reallocate budget to higher-performing activities.
  • Accurate Budget Allocation: Armed with incrementality data, we can move beyond gut feel and build a more data-driven marketing budget. This means investing more in what works and less in what doesn’t, maximising your return.

Traditionally, incrementality testing was complex and expensive. However, increasingly accessible tools and methodologies are making it viable for SMEs. Holdout groups – where a segment of your audience doesn’t receive a specific marketing message – are a common approach. Comparing the sales behaviour of the exposed and control groups reveals the incremental lift.

Don’t fall into the trap of optimising for vanity metrics. Incrementality testing provides the clarity needed to make informed decisions, ensuring your marketing budget delivers genuine, measurable results. The first step? Identify one or two key campaigns you want to test and explore the available testing platforms. Understanding your true ROI is the foundation for sustainable growth in 2026 and beyond.

The bottom line

Ready to grow?

×
Get your Free AI Marketing Audit
Find out if your website is ready for the AI revolution


    Thank you! We'll be in touch soon.