What makes testimonials effective

ROI insights

As Australian SMEs navigate an increasingly competitive landscape, customer retention is paramount. Acquiring new customers is significantly more expensive than keeping existing ones, and a powerful – yet often underutilised – tool for boosting retention is the customer testimonial. But not all testimonials are created equal. We’ve seen firsthand what separates the effective ones from those that simply gather digital dust.

Many businesses think simply *having* testimonials is enough. It’s not. To truly impact potential customers and reinforce loyalty with existing ones, testimonials need to be strategic. Here’s what we’ve learned works best:

  • Specificity is key: Vague praise like “great service” doesn’t resonate. The most impactful testimonials detail *exactly* what problem the business solved for the customer. Think: “ROI.com.au’s lead generation campaign increased our qualified leads by 35% in the first quarter, allowing us to focus on closing deals.”
  • Focus on the transformation: Customers don’t buy products or services; they buy the outcome. Testimonials should highlight the positive change experienced. Did your solution save them time, money, or stress? Did it help them achieve a specific goal? This resonates far more than feature lists.
  • Authenticity builds trust: Avoid overly polished or ‘written’ sounding testimonials. Genuine language, even with minor imperfections, feels more trustworthy. Encourage customers to speak in their own voice. Video testimonials are particularly powerful here, as they convey emotion and sincerity.
  • Targeted relevance matters: Display testimonials that address the specific concerns of the visitor viewing them. If someone is looking at your website design services, show testimonials from clients who praise your design work, not your SEO expertise.

Don’t treat testimonials as a ‘set and forget’ element of your website. Regularly solicit feedback from satisfied customers, and actively promote these stories across your marketing channels – social media, email campaigns, and even in sales presentations. Consider using a dedicated testimonials page, and integrate them strategically throughout your website. As we move into 2026, expect customers to increasingly scrutinise social proof before making purchasing decisions, making compelling testimonials even more vital.

To unlock the full potential of customer testimonials, start by identifying your happiest customers and asking them to share their experience. A simple email request can be incredibly effective. Then, focus on crafting compelling narratives that highlight the tangible benefits you deliver. This isn’t just about collecting praise; it’s about building trust and driving sustainable growth.

The bottom line

Ready to grow?

×
Get your Free AI Marketing Audit
Find out if your website is ready for the AI revolution


    Thank you! We'll be in touch soon.